LCP LCP LCP
Skip to content

Business Leadership SimulationA growing chorus of business leaders is questioning the singular notion of maximizing shareholder value. In a recent Forbes article, Jack Welch and Marc Benioff, Chairman and CEO of Salesforce, both label it the “World’s Dumbest Idea”. Neither of these CEOs think shareholder value is unimportant, but without using the label they advocate a more Balanced Leadership™ approach. Marc Benoiff in an essay in the Huffington Post calls for maximizing stakeholder value while Jack Welch says, “Shareholder value is an outcome—not a strategy.”

One of the reasons our complex business simulations resonate so well when we teach business acumen is that we, too, teach shareholder value as an outcome and stakeholder complexity as a reality.

Of the roughly 1200 minutes in a typical 3 day Insight Experience Strategic Finance Acumen program, we spend about 15 talking explicitly about shareholder value—and those minutes are towards the end. The core of our time is spent exploring and embracing the ongoing tensions that drive valuation: long term vs short term horizons, internal vs external perspectives, and analytical vs interpersonal approaches. Participants find richness and realism in the complexity (and messiness) and multiple avenues to success. Our business simulation-based programs allow leaders to explore how to push a complicated amorphous set of objectives forward together – serving customers, employees, community members and yes, shareholders, at the same time.

Perhaps it is the notion of maximizing just one variable that seems dumb and frankly, unrealistic. While the financial market pressures on a CEO are huge, they are not the only consideration. Our most senior clients routinely request our most complex simulations. They want to test themselves to consider not just multiple markets, multiple geographies and differing employee needs, but also the demands of extended stakeholders, including:

  • peer organizations competing for funds
  • regulatory bodies changing standards
  • new technological entrants meeting customer needs
  • tight employment markets
  • changing investor expectations

The real life discussions that these simulations stimulate underscore the point: leaders do not measure success with one variable nor for one stakeholder. They succeed by balancing approaches and lenses.

Roger Martin, former dean of the Rotman School may have said it best, “If [corporations] make it their purpose to maximize shareholder value, shareholders are likely to suffer because that cravenness turns off customers, employees, and the world in general. If they make it their purpose to serve customers brilliantly, be a fabulous place to work, and contribute meaningfully to the communities in which they operate, chances are their shareholders will be very happy.”

Our simulations prepare leaders for a broader definition of success in the messiness and complexity of the real world.

 

Insight Experience is a Boston-based firm delivering contextually rich, immersive business simulations and learning experiences to accelerate and integrate leadership, business acumen and strategy execution.

Subscribe to Our Blog

Let's Talk

We'd love to hear about your leadership development goals.

Leave Comment

Recent Posts

Leveraging Decision Data for Organizational Excellence-featured-image
Leveraging Decision Data for Organizational Excellence
Click to view Leveraging Decision Data for Organizational Excellence

How does your organization quantify leadership effectiveness beyond subjective self-assessment reports and...

Category:-  Featured , Business Simulation , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Leadership Illuminated: A Q&A with Women Shaping the Future-featured-image
Leadership Illuminated: A Q&A with Women Shaping the Future
Click to view Leadership Illuminated: A Q&A with Women Shaping the Future

Four years ago, just before heading back to work after the birth of my second child, I spoke to my close...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Digital Handshakes: Embracing Virtual Networking-featured-image
Digital Handshakes: Embracing Virtual Networking
Click to view Digital Handshakes: Embracing Virtual Networking

In today's evolving professional landscape, virtual networking has become vital for corporate leaders looking...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Your Guide to Bringing Strategic Leadership to Life, Part 2-featured-image
Your Guide to Bringing Strategic Leadership to Life, Part 2
Click to view Your Guide to Bringing Strategic Leadership to Life, Part 2

Back in September, in a blog post titled "Your Guide to Bringing Strategic Leadership to Life," I explored...

Category:-  Featured , Business Simulation

Learn More Click to view blog post
New Offerings to Help Your Leaders Succeed-featured-image
New Offerings to Help Your Leaders Succeed
Click to view New Offerings to Help Your Leaders Succeed

At Insight Experience, we believe in the constant evolution of our offerings to meet our clients'...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Lead from Your Feet: The Leadership Benefits of Taking a Walk-featured-image
Lead from Your Feet: The Leadership Benefits of Taking a Walk
Click to view Lead from Your Feet: The Leadership Benefits of Taking a Walk

Recently, a member of my team asked if they could sign off a bit early to go for a bike ride, “now that it...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Insightful Ideas: 2023 Flashes of Understanding-featured-image
Insightful Ideas: 2023 Flashes of Understanding
Click to view Insightful Ideas: 2023 Flashes of Understanding

A few weeks ago, a colleague sent me this (delightfully) cryptic message via Slack: "Today's NYT crossword...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Winter Wisdom: Reframing Leadership in the Quiet of the Season-featured-image
Winter Wisdom: Reframing Leadership in the Quiet of the Season
Click to view Winter Wisdom: Reframing Leadership in the Quiet of the Season

Note: This is the second blog post in our Season of Leadership series. Look for one about summer here, and...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Why Giving Tuesday Matters-featured-image
Why Giving Tuesday Matters
Click to view Why Giving Tuesday Matters

Today marks the National Day of Giving, more commonly known as Giving Tuesday, which was initiated in 2012 by...

Category:-  Featured , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post
Leadership Express Sims: Interactive Learning in a 2-4 Hour Format-featured-image
Leadership Express Sims: Interactive Learning in a 2-4 Hour Format
Click to view Leadership Express Sims: Interactive Learning in a 2-4 Hour Format

Business simulations bring complex ideas to life. Simulations enable adult learning because they engage...

Category:-  Featured , Business Simulation , Leadership

Learn More Click to view blog post